Austin Apartment Reviews Guide
Menu
Find Your Next Apartment Call
Montecito Apartments logo

Montecito Apartments

Updated 2026-07-17 · 2,441 reviewed · 809 listed · Scored from 142 Google reviews · How we rank ›

3.2(142) 58 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Luxury Apartments
Montecito Apartments
Service
Luxury Apartments
Reviews
142

What we found

Long-term residents and recent movers praise the calm location, helpful leasing staff (especially Kameron), and quick maintenance response on repair requests. The complex offers spacious units, a functional pool and gym, and walkable access to Mabel Davis Park. However, serious complaints span unchecked crime (broken security gate unfixed for over a year, theft reports), aggressive deposit deductions, pest infestations, and slow responses to major damage. Service quality appears inconsistent and tied to management changes.

The best experiences come from engaged recent tenants; the worst describe years of deterioration. Residents in their first months tend to be satisfied, while long-stayers and those needing serious repairs encounter obstacles. This is a split verdict: good amenities and occasional responsive service against mounting security and maintenance credibility issues.

Praised for
  • responsive maintenance team
  • friendly, welcoming staff
  • quiet neighborhood
  • spacious units with patios
  • resort-style pool and gym
Watch-outs
  • broken security gate not fixed for over a year
  • deposit deductions and collections disputes
  • pest problems and slow water damage response
  • property crime (theft of bikes, vehicles)
  • laundry machines frequently broken
responsive-managementwell-maintainedquiet-communityclean-common-areasfriendly-staffslow-maintenanceunresponsive-maintenancepest-problemssafe-securepackage-theft
Best for: People prioritizing quiet location and modern amenities over long-term reliability
Think twice if: Concerned about security (broken gate, reported theft) or past lease-break disputes (deposit and collections claims).

What this place gets right

  • Spacious units with private patios
  • Resort-style pool and on-site fitness center
  • Quiet neighborhood near park and transit
  • Staff responsive on routine maintenance requests

Before you tour or apply

  • Kameron praised as helpful and attentive leasing agent
  • Matt and maintenance team noted for quick routine repairs (door threshold fixed next day)
  • Water damage case: two-month resolution, no compensation for dehumidifier power; disputed early lease-break fee sent to collections
  • Roach and laundry machine issues reported across multiple reviews

Resident ratings

Luxury Apartments
Spacious, well-designed units with good patios and pool appeal on move-in; security and maintenance follow-through decline over time.

How it stacks up

  • Rated 3.2 against a 4.02 average across the 585 luxury apartments businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 52% of the businesses in this directory.

What keeps coming up

patio sizespacious apartmenthelpful teamproximity to citycleaning feequiet communityclean communityfriendly atmospherepoolmaintenance team

How we scored this

How We Score
Star rating 0
Review volume 94
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
57
4
14
3
18
2
10
1
43

FAQ

What parking is available?
On-site parking with dedicated handicap accessible spots available upon request.
Is maintenance responsive?
Routine requests like door repairs are often completed within a day. Major issues like water damage have taken two months or longer; response times vary.
What amenities are included?
Resort-style pool, fitness center, washer-dryer connections in units, community event space, and direct access to bus service.
Request a quote

Similar apartment complexes nearby

Forest Creek Village Apartments
54

Forest Creek Village Apartments

3.0(63)✓ Google-verified

Staff excel at welcoming new residents; recent arrivals praise Felicia, Rhonda, and the smooth move-in experience. However, long-term residents report catastrophic plumbing failures, widespread pest problems, and management that responds to serious health hazards with indifference. The City of Austin confirmed one unit structurally unsafe, and the complex carried 37 code violations as of 2025. Water bills run 25 times higher than comparable houses, despite the property claiming affordability.

Luxury Apartments
View profile
Burl North Apartments
58

Burl North Apartments

3.7(33)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Strong reports praise responsive staff (especially manager Shawn), quick maintenance, dog-friendly amenities, and affordability relative to location. Move-out billing disputes, unresponsiveness after tenancy, and occasional maintenance issues (mold, flooding, week-long delays) frustrate others; the surrounding neighbourhood and parking lot security also draw concern.

Luxury Apartments
View profile
Hillside Creek
59

Hillside Creek

3.4(174)✓ Google-verified

Maintenance staff-particularly Emmanuel and Mandi-earn consistent praise for quick, thorough work and genuine care. The pool, patios, and common areas are clean and well-kept. However, residents report serious safety gaps: car theft and break-ins, towing without clear notice, water shutoffs, and delayed repairs during freezing weather. Billing and collection practices draw sharp criticism; one former resident claims the complex sent a disputed charge to collections without warning or engagement despite repeated requests to resolve it. The divide is stark between frontline staff and management. Newer management appears to have improved morale since at least 2022, but core problems persist: security lapses, inconsistent maintenance on utilities, and an office that struggles with accountability when disputes arise.

Luxury Apartments
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-07-17